A note about options and investing

I have been trading options for nearly six years now.
Recently, a friend in the fund management industry asked me about how options work. So naturally I found it absurd and funny that someone whose work involves managing other people's money and beating the market is asking me to teach him how to go about doing his job. On hindsight, what I think he really meant was:
How to you make money from trading options in a short time?
Fortunately I manage my own money, because both questions are red flags to me for someone who has spent many years in finance working on the buyside.
Owning an option allows you the right to do something. Selling it gives someone else that right. It is a simple concept.
If you think about it, it is pretty similar to how insurance works: You make a bet on the occurrence of a certain event taking place––falling sick, getting into an accident, dying––and then getting a huge payout if and when it happens. But you can make that wager only if someone is willing to transact with you.
Insurance companies derive income from selling policies, Traders get theirs by writing options. That is why they call it a premium.
In some ways options trading is gambling, and gambling involves taking a view on a particular outcome. This is not vastly different from taking a view on the economy or how a company will perform in the future. Stock goes up, you win, other party loses. Stock goes down you lose. It doesn't get more complicated than that. But entry to the global gambling den of stocks isn't free, you have to pay to play and there must be sufficient players in the room. The mechanics of the game are in the rules set by the house--the stock exchange and brokers.
Of course the markets work in more complex ways. Many people think they are in control of the outcome––for example, where interest rates are headed and its impact on the market, whether investors will buy into the narrative of a company’s new product launch, the replacement of a CEO, etc.
I am not saying that we shouldn’t look at the data and analyze the possible outcomes. It would be unwise to make a call on whether a company is undervalued or overvalued before first considering the factors at play, including the quality and source of information.
But the truth is that we sometimes take an overly measured approach to quantifying risk and precise performance indicators, but fail to appreciate that not everything goes according to plan.
When the going gets tough, most of everything that is learned about fair value gets thrown out of the window. For all our expertise in being able to assess risk, humans generally do not respond well when outcomes deviate from what we expect.
You would be naive to think that knowledge of corporate finance and valuation alone will get you far in the investing world.
Best I can summarise:
My investing thesis with options and equities is pretty much like a man walking a dog on a leash.
The man is what a stock should cost i.e. the perceived intrinsic value. The dog is what it actually costs i.e. the market price.
The dog runs ahead and the dog falls behind. But there is a leash. So eventually it comes back. And that is the whole trade.
Dog too far ahead, you sell the dog and buy the man. Dog too far behind, you do the opposite. You wait. You never bet on where they are going, whether uphill, downhill or into traffic. You only bet on the gap.
For many years this has been a lovely model. The leash is a spring. The leash stretches past the line and it snaps back. Until the dog meets a squirrel.

Note: The walking dog was adapted off some social media post that I can't remember where now.



